1. St. Joseph the Worker
    March 19, 2019
    Very Rev. Denis Robinson, OSB
    Your house and your kingdom shall endure forever before me;
    your throne shall stand firm forever.
    The promise made to King David in today’s first reading puts me in mind of a quote by the English author, George Eliot. 
    The growing good of the world is partly dependent on unhistoric acts; and that things are not so ill with you and me as they might have been, is half owing to the number who lived faithfully a hidden life, and rest in unvisited tombs. 
    That quote, and our feast today makes me think of the important question of legacy, reputation, inheritance.  

    What will our legacy be? As a leader, I think about this quite a bit. What will this or that action do to either facilitate or damage the reputation of Saint Meinrad? We must think about how our lives are lived today, but there must also be a little fraction of our mind that is looking toward the future. 

    What will your legacy be here? Will you be the one whose memory is so dear to all who live here, to all students and faculty alike? Or will you be the one unremembered and perhaps gratefully forgotten as even a short time rolls on?

    What will your legacy be in your parishes? Will you go there filled with hope, dreams, ideas, and energy? Will you become the one who changes things in that parish, the one they name a hall after in years to come? Or will you be just a fading picture on a wall, easily forgotten because your “greener pastures” were waiting and you really didn’t have much time for St. Aloysius. 

    What will your legacy be in your dioceses? Long remembered or easily forgotten, the unassignable priest or the invaluable member of a presbyterate, temperamental or willing to go to any corner of the Lord’s vineyard, not because it is lucrative, but because you are needed there. 
    Your house and your kingdom shall endure forever before me;
    your throne shall stand firm forever.
    All of us are building our legacy. You know we are, day by day, minute by minute. Perhaps we call it something else like reputation or heritage or remnant or vestige, what about your memory?

    Perhaps each of us is building a legacy of words, or kind and gentle words offered in a time when our brothers are most in need, offered in the heat of emotion or the desolation of mourning. Here is a word well placed and well timed to heal a broken spirit, a heart beset with pain or sin. 

    Perhaps we are building a legacy of action, little anonymous gifts of food left here, or a little money left there. Perhaps we are building a heritage of goodness and love in what might seem like empty gestures but mean to world to a soul in need. 

    For good or for ill we are building our legacy of words and actions, day by day, all of the time. 
    Your house and your kingdom shall endure forever before me;
    your throne shall stand firm forever.
    What will that house be? That kingdom? That throne? I wonder …

    Today we honor St. Joseph, a man of his time, nothing less, nothing more. A young man perhaps, we know he was a man accustomed to dreaming. What did he dream of? A new workshop? A houseful of children? A wife to gently nag him? As a man of his time he must have dreamt of all of these: A little drink with the boys, a hearty Sabbath celebration, kids screaming at their games, a legacy of ordinariness? 

    He did not get it, but rather he built another kind of legacy

    A legacy of virtue

    A legacy of sacrifice

    A legacy of miracle making in the very heart of the ordinary

    St. Joseph also built another legacy, a legacy of silent service 

    Is that us as well? Is that what we are called to do?

    Is that what the Lord wants for us? Nothing flashy, nothing false, just service in the household of the Divine King day after day, year after year; a Divine King that looks for all the world like a bald-headed, screaming Jewish baby. 

    And yet, St. Joseph must have also known these prophetic words:
    Your house and your kingdom shall endure forever before me;
    your throne shall stand firm forever.
    He must have known them, but I wonder if he knew they applied to him. I’ll bet he never thought about that. 

    I am reminded of another quote by George Eliot: 
    What do we live for, if not to make life less difficult for each other?
    Certainly … certainly that was the very heart of the legacy of Joseph’s life

    What, I wonder shall our legacy be?

    Image Source



  2. Priesthood Promises
    March 14, 2019
    Very Rev. Denis Robinson, OSB

    Ask and it will be given to you;
    seek and you will find;
    knock and the door will be opened to you.
    In the context of the Mass this evening we celebrate with our deacon brothers the first concrete step in their upcoming ordination to the priesthood. I don’t think we can stand here, in the shadow of the cross and fail to acknowledge that they make these promises in troubling times, which is all the more reason these promises must mean something important, not only for them but for our Church who listens attentively to these promises, hoping that in them we will hear the syllables of renewal and reconciliation. 

    What will they proclaim?

    They will proclaim their freedom, freedom in a time in which the free exercise of the will is coming under attack from so many messages in our culture that tell us what we are supposed to think and how we are supposed to be. Is there the possibility of exercising freedom of will in a world seemingly under the spell of bastardized notions of liberty and libertarianism?

    Tonight our brothers will offer an oath of fidelity. In a world where the idea of fidelity is ridiculed, where family and its enduring quality is under attack, where fathers and mothers no longer promote the ideals of vocations in their children, how can fidelity be maintained? How can it persevere? How can we trust authority, particularly the authorities presented for us in the Church today when that trust has been so sorely eroded by crises of abuse and cover-up?

    Tonight our brothers will make a profession of faith. We could offer high sounding phrases about the profession of faith, but we know the value of our creed, we know the blood that stains each word of this holy testament, we know how its syllables connect us to all of those men and women, those saints of God who have professed it while endless ages have rolled. We know how these prophetic words have struck and stung the scorpions of human pride. We know how their utterance has confounded heresy and the tyranny of human ambitions. We know how they draw us back to the waters of our baptism, where we rejected one world and promised to live for another, a kingdom of this world, and a kingdom of the world to come. 

    These are hard promises to make in turbulent times, but here we have brothers, men whose lives have been forged in the crucible of trouble and cured over time. We have men ready to make these dramatic promises, promises made on the altar, promises made with a guarantee in mind:
    Ask and it will be given to you;seek and you will find;knock and the door will be opened to you.
    Let’s depart for a moment to some little bit of reverie. Let us think back on how these vocations, coming tonight to this decisive moment, began.

    For some it began in those early days of childhood, in playing Mass, in making vestments by cutting holes in old sheets and putting some grape juice in mom’s old Fostoria goblet. Here the young play-priest heard the invitation to ask and receive.

    For some it began in those pimple plastered years of adolesence, in a voice speaking over the wind of other temptations, in the face of being different, in the face of ridicule, that voice was heard over the pressures of peers: Seek and you will find.

    For some it came in the firestorm of conversion, of seeing God face to face at a moment of crisis, in the call of an early morning, in the face of personal disaster: Knock and the door will be opened for you. 

    For some it came by the example of a priest who worked hard, who gave boring sermons, who said mass in a raspy voice but who was also a martyr of love, love poured out in service day and night of the people of God in his little corner of the vineyard: Ask, only ask and you shall receive.

    Brothers and sisters that call of Christ, that voice of Christ is still crying out today, crying out over the din of popularism, crying out over the insistent beckoning of a life of mendacity, calling out with a clarion call over the hills of injustice and the mountains of prejudice and bigotry. 

    All of us hear have heard something of that call, something of that symphonic music echoing against the walls of cynicism and fear and doubt. The words of the Lord have been clear to us all: “Follow me and I will make you fishers of men”, and here we are, standing here, not only these brothers but all of us, gathered here tonight, standing on the promises of God. 

    Because more miraculous and more wonderful than the promises made by our brothers tonight is the promise that God offers to us, to each of us, in our turn, in our sin, in our indifference, in our confusion, in our pain, in our doubt. 
    Ask and it will be given to you;seek and you will find;knock and the door will be opened to you.
    Do we believe it? Can we believe it? 

    The promises of God are sure and firm. Our promises made to God must also be sure and firm. Tonight you face this congregation in making your promises, but those promises will be fulfilled in other fields, in other vineyards. 

    Who will you find there but a melange of faith-filled and faith-shaken men and women and children caught up in the drama of life, real life. They are running a race with blinders on. Lead them. Help them. And then, beg them to lead you, to help you. Lord I believe, help my unbelief. This must be the continual prayer of the priest. Find examples for your own faith in the faith of old ladies gathered for the early morning Mass. Find your own faith in that of young fathers and mothers soldiering along under the most un-endurable circumstance. Find your own faith in those early morning rosaries prayed too fast, in those caught moments of prayer between basketball and ballet. Find your own faith in the faith they have to confess the same petty sins repeatedly in the sacrament of reconciliation. Find your own faith in their hard questions to which you have such poor answers. Find your onw faith in their seeking for Truth, the Truth of the Gospel, the Truth only Christ in God can supply. Find your own faith, your own full stature in helping the hunched frames of your future congregations stand erect and proud. 
    Ask and it will be given to you;seek and you will find;knock and the door will be opened to you.
    We ask and God answers. We seek and God provides. We knock and the opportunity for service, for vocation, for living truly authentic lives is opened to us. I hope that is what we represent in this community of faith.

    My brothers, my dear deacons, your time at Saint Meinrad is coming to a close. In the coming months you will leave us, some of you for the very last time. Some of you will go away in tears. Some of you will be leaping for joy. You will no longer have the daily support of seminary life to keep you faithful to the promises you make. You will have to be sustained by humility, the humility to ask, to seek, to knock. God will be true to His word. He will give you the strength to be true to yours. Yes brothers in a little while you will be going away, but we will remain, this community of faith, striving to do what we have always done. If you need Saint Meinrad in the coming months or years you need only ask, seek, knock upon our door and you will find us ready to answer and open the door to invite you in, just as the Lord Jesus opens the door of his Body and Blood to us in this Eucharist. We sustain ourselves by that promise.
    Ask and it will be given to you;seek and you will find;knock and the door will be opened to you.
    Tonight, have no fear God has made the promise first, and he will most assuredly fulfill it.

    Image Source



  3. Fourth Rector's Conference
    March 10, 2019
    Very Rev. Denis Robinson, OSB
    See how the Cross of Christ stands revealed as the tree of life
    The antiphon from the Office of Readings today offers us a great deal of insight into the mystery we celebrate each year in this season of Lent
    See how the Cross of Christ stands revealed as the tree of life
    On our annual Rome trip, one of the places I like to visit is the Church of Santa Croce in Jerusalem. The basilica is located near the Cathedral of St. John Lateran and is built over the former home of the mother of the Emperor Constantine, St. Helen. When St. Helen went to the Holy Land to search for the cross of Christ and the place of Calvary, she had inspired good fortune, locating not only the place upon which the present Church of the Holy Sepulcher is built, but also the instruments of the Passion, the cross, the nails, the crown of thorns, the title.

    She returned home to Rome with these treasures and built a great church on her on property but before she built the church, she imported literally tons of dirt from the city of Jerusalem so that the great reliquary could literally be in Jerusalem, thus the name of the Church.

    Through the years, the “relic of the True Cross” has been splintered and has proliferated, being found in place around the world, some of which St. Helen could have never dreamt of. Of course, we do not need to have the physical remnant of the Cross in order to understand its power, we are, after all, professionals in the Church world, exploring in infinite ways the nature of metaphor, image, symbol, sacrament.

    What does the cross mean for us?

    The cross of Christ connects us to the passion. This year on Good Friday we will all celebrate the solemn unveiling of the cross, we will approach it with reproaches. We will venerate it, each in his own way and we will feel it. We will undoubtedly as we do each year, feel the power of the cross at that moment, understand, even without words, its impact in our lives, in the life of everyone who creeps upon the earth. The cross of Christ connects us to the passion. And …

    The cross of Christ is the directional sign that unites east and west, north and south. The cross points in all directions and therefore brings in all peoples. Here is this man struggling to keep his family alive in war-torn Syria, here is the woman bravely raising her child alone, here is the boy abandoned in the streets of a South American city. Here is the girl, harboring her brother and sisters in poverty stricken Africa. The cross of Christ is a directional sign. And …

    The cross of Christ is the moral compass by which we guide our lives. All of us are drawn into that saving flood pouring down from the face of Christ. All of us are standing in the need of prayer tonight and every night of our lives. All of us are drawn into the circle of that compass, that place in which the authentic story of mankind is written in the syllables of sacrifice. The cross of Christ is a moral compass. And …
    The cross of Christ is an instrument of torture. See how our Lord, innocent and without sin, was nailed to the wood of that cross. See how his sacred, God-like body was rent asunder by its awful justice. See how it tortures us in our damnable complacency.  And …
    See how the Cross of Christ stands revealed as the tree of life
    The cross of Christ takes us back to the beginning, to Adam and Eve in the garden, to the disastrous choice they made there, to the fall, that awful fall by which all of our woe was introduced into the world and thus initiated a testament of evil.

    The cross of Christ draws us back to the failure of our forebears, to Israel and its frantic desire to create a covenant with its Creator, a guarantee of salvation even in the face of rancid evil.

    The cross of Christ points us back to the tower of Babel, to the introduction of cacophony in the world, of speaking languages inimical to the unified and unifying language of love.

    The cross of Christ points us back to Noah, to that patented, pathetic remnant of a the family of humankind standing on the flood-soaked deck of that ship hauling the refuse of the world and riding the arc of a rainbow into a newness that would soon be sullied yet again.

    The cross of Christ harbors that rock upon which old Abraham, listening to the voice of the Almighty, brought his only son, his hope, brought him to the brink of a sacrificial death only to have his hand stayed by an angel, introducing into the world a series of meaningless sacrifices committed by wood, the smoke of lambs and doves rising as dissipating ash into the stratosphere.

    The cross of Christ is the tree that caught young Absalom by his hair even as he betrayed his father David.

    The cross of Christ is fashioned from those cedars of Lebanon by which the paneling of the old Temple of Solomon was made holy.

    The cross of Christ is the platform upon which those prophets spoke, raising their voices over and against the din of deception. It is that wood upon which their petitions were inscribed, nailed to the doors of the sanctuary

    The cross of Christ is that evil in history by which it seemed, that the lessons God intended to teach could not be learned. That lesson could not be learned because for all of the wood in the world, no one could teach those lessons, not judges, not kings, not prophets. The evil in history persisted like a gross spider or a virus, infecting the human race

    Wars and destruction and greed and lust prevailed, it could not be overcome by all of the smoking wood-drunk sacrifices of the Temple. And yet …
    See how the Cross of Christ stands revealed as the tree of life
    The cross here in this sanctuary stands as a sentinel to remind us of the power of evil that still can hold sway in our lives and in our world. It exists today in powerful leaders who do not care about their people. It persists in folks whose outrageous wealth makes them insensate to the cries of the poor. It exists in our lives as malevolence to overcome, or to which to wield. It exists in our sullenness and our snarkiness. It exists in our selfishness and our pride. It exists in our failure to acknowledge that we are weak, we are complexly and utterly dependent upon one thing, one thing only: The Cross of Christ.

    In this Lenten season, we are called to examine the cross of Christ for what it is. Why did God become man? The answer is simple, and utterly mysterious. God became a man to accomplish what only God could accomplish. He became a man to pay the debt that only Man owed.
    See how the Cross of Christ stands revealed as the tree of life
    And so we are called to cling to the cross. We are compelled to worship the cross, because we know the evil of the world and the evil which lurks in our hearts.

    We know that we look for countless things to save us, even here. We look to our personalities, our wealth, our intellect, our spiritual accomplishments, our cunning.

    Even here, in the shadow of the cross, we experience the essential vacuum that is inside each of us and we try to fill that space, that void illegitimately with food, with drink, with sex, with friends, with the entertainment.

    There is nothing less becoming to a priesthood lived in the shadow of the cross than frivolity, freely chosen as a way of life.

    Here in this house of formation we are called to realize in the shadow of the cross that we are told, reminded when we look upon the crucifix that it is our openness to the cross, our openness to the invitation of the cross that is our only hope in this troubled world, our only salvation for the next.
    See how the Cross of Christ stands revealed as the tree of life
    How do we approach the cross?

    Like the mother of Jesus, cradling memories hugging those dear feet and remembering in its pierced shadows the tiny feet that first kicked straw in a manger in Bethlehem.

    Like the mother who hears in her mind’s ear angel wings, white-grey-green beating furiously an invitation
    Will you? Fiat. Who knew it could lead to this?

    Like the mother who sees in the brow of her child the strickeness of people who have traversed gardens and fields and hilltops and heard thorn bushes speak with scarce more eloquence than these thorns as they strike the veins of the Eternal Word.

    Like the mother whose grief speaks secret joy because she alone knows the Truth: That her Son is dying for all, for her, for his tormentors, for these thieves.
    See how the Cross of Christ stands revealed as the tree of life
    How do we approach the cross?

    Do we approach the cross like Joseph of Arimathea?

    There is blood in the crook of my arm

    This is the thought of Joseph of Arimathea

    His blood is in the crook of my arm

    It smells of iron, of metal

    It is strangely sticky

    And now I am unclean for the Passover

    Unclean through the blood of the only source of healing, cleanliness

    Like Joseph do we approach knowing that the old order has passed away, that the very law is passed over?

    That our sins are passed over.
    See how the Cross of Christ stands revealed as the tree of life
    Do we fear what this cross means for our future, for our past, for our lives of sin even as we embrace it, acknowledge it?

    Do we fear for ourselves as we approach the cross?

    Perhaps we approach the cross like John?

    Eager to prove our worth, our steadfastness, our trust

    Or like Peter, not at all

    Or like the women full of tears for a passion that is more ours than his?

    Or like Nicodemus with his preposterous hundred pounds of tribute spices, the gift of the un-committed, the shame of the unconvinced who come to Him only under cover of darkness

    Or like ourselves

    Men and women in need of embracing its wood, seeing in its wood our featly to one who

    Though he was in the form of God Jesus did not deem equality with God something to be held on to.

    Sometime we can get caught up in the very dourness of the cross that we lose sight of the larger picture.

    And yet, see how the Cross of Christ stands revealed as the tree of life, for the cross is a conduit, a means, a necessary means but only a means.

    What is the end?

    Joy – Real, true, eternal, lasting Joy

    Tonight as we contemplate the cross, as we stand here in the beginning of Lent, I am reminded of the poem of Emily Dickinson:
    After great pain a formal feeling comes--
    The nerves sit ceremonious like tombs;
    The stiff Heart questions--was it He that bore?
    And yesterday--or centuries before?
    The feet, mechanical, go round
    A wooden way
    Of ground, or air, or ought,
    Regardless grown,
    A quartz contentment, like a stone.
     
    This is the hour of lead
    Remembered if outlived,
    As freezing persons recollect the snow--
    First chill, then stupor, then the letting go.
    Image Source

  4. Ash Wednesday
    March 6, 2019
    Very Rev. Denis Robinson, OSB
    Rend your hearts, not your garments, and return to the LORD, your God.

    The mandate seems very clear and it is one we encounter each year at this time, even if the time is a little bit later this year. Better late than never, an adage which of course is not always true.

    Perhaps this Lent will be different. Perhaps we can authentically find something in this Lent to enlighten us, to stimulate us in our faith, because the season is, after all, a question of faith.

    What is the status of your faith? We all like to think that we are good men and women of faith, that we are engaging in parishes that are full of faith, that we are part of a Church that is the epitome of faith.

    It would be nice, if only it were true. Which is not to say that we are not those things, we are, of course. But we also know that we can be half-hearted, milky, watered down. We can be tip-toers, fearful people who don’t want to muck things up too much. In other words, sometimes in the practice of our faith, even here, we can be exactly those people that our Lord so strenuously opposed. The lukewarm and the cautious

    Brothers and sisters, as we come into this Lenten season, this season of renewal, I think it’s time to get a bit out of control.  I think we need it. If our work here, our formation here means anything, it is imperative that a radical conversion be in the works.
    We need to get revolutionary because we have all become too complacent
    We need to get a bit wild in this Lent because we have been lulled into the lie that our whole lives are not dependent upon the faith we profess here.
    Is this chapel just a hideout or a temporary place of refuge or do we find our deepest meaning here, our whole selves here?
    I believe we need something a bit out of the ordinary because the world is going to continually tell us that our faith is only something quaint and accessorizing.

    Now listen again to the words of the prophet:
    Even now, says the LORD, return to me with your whole heart, with fasting, and weeping, and mourning; Rend your hearts, not your garments, and return to the LORD, your God.

    Can our Lent be a meaningless, mealy mouthed event if we take seriously the words of the prophet?
    Must it not be a life changing event? Even for us here, even for experts in the faith?

    Let’s go back now to the words of Jesus in the Gospel:

    When you pray
    When you fast
    When you give alms
    Please notice, in Jesus’ world there are no conditionals. He does not say, if, he says when but we often think of Lent as a time for if’s and not when’s.
       
    What is Lent in the popular imagination? I propose that it is an unbridled season of often misconstrued and quite often unrealized, possibility.
    What you are giving up for Lent?
    How can I get out of that?
    What are the laws that govern these practices?
    Outdated laws
    Silly practices
    Useless SYMBOLISM in the face of a call to radical conversion.

    We do not take the call of God seriously even in this environment and we are bewildered that lukewarmness and a real lack of commitment exist, out there.

    O certainly, spiritual trumpets are blown, faces are besmirched with the dirt of resentment, room doors are flung open to display the flagrant acts of asceticism taking place within.
    We commit ourselves to our good works and fail.
    We submit our robust flesh to the relentlessness of exercise programs and fail.
    We strive to be the most abstemious and we fail.

    And in all of this unheard of sacrifice and heroic neglect of self, what happens?
    Nothing, of course
    And all of this is accompanied by the rhetoric and cadences of a spiritual tokenism.
    We sigh
    We cry
    We try

    Here is the question I ask this community of faith every year …

    Where is this Lent leading us?
    What do we want to BE on the other side of Lent?
    What destination are we aiming for in this annual pilgrimage of discipleship?
    How might this Lent be truly a time of difference?
    Remember the words of the prophet? 
    Rend your hearts, not your garments, and return to the LORD, your God.

    What if we could learn to give to others and experience the pinch a bit rather than scraping the bottom of the barrel of life for a couple of coins to hurl in the general direction of the in our estimation probably undeserving poor.

    What if our alms cut us, hurt us, caused us to feel in our flesh the needs of the poor and the downcast? What if we could learn to give the alms of unfulfilled love?

    And what about our prayer? What if, instead of the endless litany of this or that we learned to weep pitifully in the presence of the Lord? What if we could pray in those early hours of the morning without looking around to judge those who were there or not there?

    What if our prayer could truly open the chambers of our hearts to seek new ways to learn to close our mouths? What if our prayer could bring others to Christ, our prayer rather than our collection of beer? What if our prayer could be so attractive that our brothers and here could be converted to the power of the Gospel, because I can assure you, we all need to be converted to the power of the Gospel. What if we talked more to our neighbors about the joy of prayer and less about the misery of seminary life?

    Then we might find ourselves gaining softness in those open hearts. Then we might find ourselves able to nakedly reveal our struggles and pains. Then we might learn to love with an unfettered love. Then we might become true priests of the crucified and risen Christ.

    What if we could learn how to truly fast, to deny ourselves those things which really mean very little in the larger scheme, our attitudes and opinions?
    What if our fasting led to something rather than just misery, what if it led to new ways of living and new paths of conversion?
    Rend your hearts, not your garments, and return to the LORD, your God.

    To me, that is a revolutionary message, that is the invitation to a season of transformation, a season of real growth and change. It is a season in which everything must be rethought and conversion be permanent, not a tokenistic giving up.

    That rending and returning draws us ever closer to the promise of the resurrection

    What do we expect to do on Easter Sunday? Do we expect to rise with Christ victorious over sin and death? Do we expect to rise with Christ victorious over ourselves? Do we expect to rise with Christ over the ashes of our sins? Do we expect to rise new and glorious men and women>

    Or do we expect to just return to our old ways, the damnable malaise of a conventional faith?  
    Rend your hearts, not your garments, and return to the LORD, your God.






  5. Ash Wednesday Conference
    March 6, 2019
    Very Rev. Denis Robinson, OSB

    Lent is an appropriate time, I believe, for us to do what we do every day in a more concrete way: Examine our conscience. Every evening at compline we take a moment to review our day and to think about ways we have failed, and hopefully, about ways we have succeeded in realizing our primary vocations of following God in Christ. If you are like me, this can sometimes, perhaps quite often, seem somewhat perfunctory, a little rote, at the end of a long day.

    Yes Lord, I have sinned.

    Yes Lord, I am sorry for my sins. I said the act of contrition didn’t I?

    Attitude. Attitude. Attitude.

    Perhaps in this season of Lent we are offered a chance to do in a more focused way what we frequently skip over in our daily acts of examination.

    And so today, standing as we are on the threshold of this penitential season, I would like to ask some questions, perhaps relating to you, perhaps to us, certainly to me. Let’s consider this a collective act of examination.

    Let us begin broadly: What is the spiritual condition of our Church, writ large?

    I would say, if we are honest, we have to admit that it is reeling. It is difficult to maintain an upright consciousness of the Church when it is being subjected to so many attacks from without, with the full realization that many, if not all, of those attacks are fully justified. It does not mean that it is comfortable to see some of our priests, and some truly beloved priests, dragged through the mud for insciedents that may have happened many years ago. We know that justice must be done, that is a moral absolute, but it does not make justice comfortable. We know that there are bishops in our Church who have done their part in robbing our Church of her moral credibility and we must disdain that behavior, if not disdain the man. Sometimes that is difficult. It is hard to find room in my little store of compassion for Mr. Ted McCarrick. I received a letter the other day from a lady I don’t think I have ever met. She had read something on the abuse crisis that I had written and she said: I had such hopes for Pope Francis when he was elected. A good deal of that hope is now gone in the wake of so many scandals. I feel sorry for those in our Church who may feel the same way. If I am honest, I also feel sorry for myself, that while I have a full conviction in the ultimate divine nature of the Church and its invincibility, there are days when my faith is pushed to the very limit. I hope that gives me, very superficially, some level of solidarity with those who are suffering now.

    I go back and say, the condition of our Church is reeling. I know that it will ultimately right itself but that does not make this storm-tossed journey in the ark of Peter any easier today, in this time, during this season of Lent. Our Church is in trouble. God will right that trouble but we must do our part as well. Part of “our part” is being honest with our struggles, but another part of “our part” is defending the Church, standing up for her apologetically. One way in which we do this is to have in our hearts an understanding for victims and an understanding for those who abuse. None of us want to hear this latter part but it is true. We must have compassion for those who have abused others. If we cannot have mercy on this sinner without excusing him, then what hope have we to be agents of reconciliation for others, much less able to forgive ourselves? When we say the examination of conscience in the evening, when we ask for mercy, can we find it in our hearts to authentically seek God’s mercy for abusers? Can we ask for their reconciliation, their forgiveness? Can we pray for their souls, in spite of what they have done to the Church? That is the role of the priest. That is what you are preparing for, not to be men of judgement and condemnation, not to be executioners, but to be angels of mercy called to the sickbed of humanity.

    Now, perhaps, that spirit of examination we need so much in this Lent might be drawn closer to home. What is the condition of this community? Let me begin by saying this is a good community. If it was anything other than a good community, I can assure you I would put the blame for that squarely on my shoulders. Is it a perfect community? No. Is it a community that fulfills the expectations of everyone here, their personal biases and tastes? No. If that were the case, it would most certainly be a schizophrenic community. What is the condition of members of this community? Here we must realize something that may be shocking, that is, we must realize the truth: We are sinners. We are a community of sinners. If we can know that individually, then we can have a great deal more trust in the system. In this day and age, there must be trust in the system. If you do not trust the seminary, if you do not trust the formation you are receiving here. If you have come to be your own formator, that needs to change, or you need to go. An anti-institutional attitude does not bode well in the priest. I hope that we do not give you the ammunition you need to distrust us. However, if you are by nature on the lookout for that ammunition, you will undoubtedly find it, at least in your imagination.

    I also think in this Lenten season, we do well to reflect on ourselves. In my estimation there are four kinds of seminarians, even though I certainly recognize that all are unique, and wonderfully so, I see certain trends unfolding over time. The first type is the one who comes to Saint Meinrad with a certain set of expectations. He knows what a priest should be and he knows what a formation program should be. He is wise beyond his years, or so he thinks. This sort of man spends his time with us judging the place according to whether or not it meets his expectations and his values. He takes those aspects of formation that meet his ideals. He accepts the faculty members that say the things he believes must be said. He rejects the rest. He does not change. He does not convert during his time with us. This pattern, the stubborn, intellectual narcissist is not a good candidate for priesthood, because his priesthood will be riddled with the same brokenness he brings to formation. He cannot accept what the French call difference. He cannot live into mystery. He must write the script himself.

    The second sort of man also comes with a set of expectations. He knows everything when he arrives, but soon learns that there are aspects of priestly service and life, indeed aspects of God he hasn’t yet fully fathomed. In the course of his time here, he will be taken apart and put back together. His new reality will also be confident but it will not be built upon his ideas and ideals alone, but upon the Church’s need, the Church’s desire. This man is open to the Spirit in a way the first man is not. He has the ability to change his mind and is happy to do so. He listens to everything, prays over all of it, accepts what is necessary, files away the rest for perhaps further reflection. This man, in the seminary, establishes a pattern that will see him successfully through the rest of his life. He will hear the voices of the people he will serve. He will delight in the surprises that God will hold out for him and, finally, he will look back with nostalgia on his former, cocksure self and laugh a little at how immature he was, all the time rejoicing in how his God has given him wisdom beyond what he could have imagined.

    The third sort of man is the one who comes to seminary as a tabula rasa. In our current climate of infinite discernment, these boys are a bit rare. He doesn’t have a set of expectations. He is happy to admit he knows very little about what he is getting into. He places himself completely in our hands. This can be helpful. It can also be a problem in that one wonders where his faith journey has taken him thus far and how that journey has left him with no lasting imprint. I remember distinctly my first week in the seminary. We were having those insufferable “sharing” sessions and one of the new guys confided: I really don’t know if I want to be a Catholic or an Episcopalian. He didn’t last. These men can be quite malleable, but there is a great deal of work to do. It can be done however, and there is the benefit of their openness to hearing the Good News of formation.

    Finally, there is the last kind of seminarian. This one is the dark horse, or what I call the submarine. He comes with nothing, or at least nothing he is telling and for four or six years the staff never learns a thing about him. He rides the wave of anonymity. He doesn’t let on that there is anything at all going on. He sees a spiritual director all of that time and the director is no wiser after years of meeting than he was at the beginning. This kind of submarining is something that the seminary staff must root out. On the one hand we must ask why he is so unwilling to share his faith with us. On the other, a lack of knowledge must lead us to speculate as to why a man who proposes to dedicate his life to the evangelical call of going out to all the world and telling the Good News remains so secretive about his own faith journey. All in all, it is better to deal with a loudmouth narcissist, than a submarine. At least with the narcissist you know where you stand.

    I believe the question we must ask ourselves is simple as we embark on this Lenten pilgrimage: Who do you want to be? What kind of a priest do you want to be? Lent is a time for putting away everything that keeps us from fully engaging our formation. That is true whether we are in the seminary, in the monastery, no matter. Lent trains our eyes and our ears, the eyes of our minds and the ears of our hearts to be attuned to the promptings of the Spirit. I think that is especially important in this time of crisis for the Church.

    Of course, there is variation and there is success. There is triumph and there is brokenness. Every day we examine our consciences and, if we are honest, we find many things there. Day to day, week to week, year to year. Our ability to listen to the promptings of God through these daily things is a gauge of our success as priests. My ability to overcome the storms of the day, including the storms of the Church, is a barometer of success. That does not mean putting it aside or shielding ourselves from trouble. That means looking trouble in the face and calling it by its name. Sometimes it means, finally spitting at it.

    On my desk, I have a little glass snowman. I have had it for many years and frankly, I don’t remember who gave it to me. He is a holiday snowman. He is smiling and happy to the last degree. He wears mittens, a scarf and a red Santa hat, all of which seem highly non-intuitive for a snowman. He has a cord coming out of his snow backside and he is connected to the computer. Interiorly, he changes color, shifting every few seconds from blue, to red, to yellow, to green. When I pay attention to him, which isn’t often, I note that he is like me. Smiling and happy on the outside, but sometimes, not all the time, but sometimes blue on the inside. Trying hard on the outside but red with anger on the inside. Healthy on the outside, but yellow with sickness on the inside. Then of course, happy on the outside and filled with green life on the inside. I hope that is how we can be most of the time, that is what I hope for in the long term. Being a priest is hard. Being a seminarian is hard. Being a faculty or staff member is hard. Our life is hard, but even in that, even in a broken Church, even in a miserable Lent, the joy of a green spring breaks upon us, a new Easter beckons.




  6. Deacon Promises - 2019
    February 21, 2019
    Very Rev. Denis Robinson, OSB 

    Today in Rome, we witnessed the first day of the historic occasion of the extraordinary gathering of conference presidents, summoned by the pope for the purpose of discussion of the sexual abuse crisis

    Today we are hearing about the situation in the Roman dicastery that provides guidelines for dealing with the children of priests

    Today we are reading stories about the cardinal from India who seemingly did not have time to meet with victims of abuse because he was going to Rome to be important

    Today we continue to hear stories about Mr. McCarrick and all of the other bishops and cardinals who have sown the seeds of scandal in their respective fields and today are reaping that dubious harvest

    Today we are reading stories about religious sisters molested and persecuted by priests and bishops in different places in the world.

    Today the Church is reeling over a book written by a French journalist that seems to expose a vast homosexual culture in the Vatican

    Today like every day there seems to be a new story about scandal. We ask ourselves, does the Church offer us anything else? Does the Vatican offer us anything else?

    That is today. What will tomorrow bring?

    If you are like me, you are tired, really sick to death of hearing about scandal in the Church. I am sick and tired of it, and yet, I know the conversation must go on. But not tonight.

    Tonight, we must concentrate our spiritual and mental energies on these men who are about to make their promises for ordination.

    After many and long years of formation, we come tonight to a crossroads, a decisive moment.

    Through these promises and through the long years of ordained service that they initiate, you, my brothers will be asked daily to decide if you are going to be the future of a damaged Church, or if you will instead be part of the problem.

    Will you be part of the problem by engaging your formidable energies in backstabbing and backbiting which has become the favored pastime of some of your brothers in the presbyterate?

    Will you become a part of the problem by living secret lives addicted to pornography or alcohol?

    Will you be a part of the problem by failing to pray, by neglecting the people of God in their need for service by their priests?

    Will you become a part of the problem by being a son of the Church in your attire and in your zeal to uphold the law, but a son of a bitch in your attitude about God’s people?

    I hope not. I think not.

    Tonight in these promises we witness your potential, we hear of it in the words you are about to publicly proclaim

    Tonight in these promises you will vow yourselves to uphold the teaching of the Church, certainly, but also the Holy Spirit of that teaching in a way some of your clerical brothers have failed to do.

    Tonight in these promises, you will vow yourselves to bring pride to your local Church, your families, your parishes, by being humble servants of God’s will and not men who lord their authority and their real power over others.

    Tonight in these promises, you will vow yourselves to divorce yourselves from the Church’s politics, from fragmenting battles over liturgical niceties, from acidic comments about your brothers behind the scenes and put on Christ, who came to serve and not to be served, who gave himself completely to the world immersed in political wrangling and scandal.

    Tonight in these promises, you will vow yourselves to God and to us, you will vow yourself to put away childish things and put on the armor of Christ.

    Tonight in these promises you will vow yourselves to a new sobriety of thought and action, a new sensitivity to the needs of your brothers and sisters, first and foremost by serving your brothers and sisters in humble ways here.

    Tonight in these promises you will vow yourselves to a new sensitivity to the suffering of the world, the ache of those hurt by others, even by the Church, that institution that has been established by God to support and uphold those faltering in sin.

    Tonight in these promises, you will vow yourselves to be men of action, men who listen, men who weep, men who comfort, men who find their true masculinity in the brokenness of Christ, the man of grief who hung upon the cross for us.

    Tonight in these promises, you will vow yourselves to love, to love without counting the cost, to love until the end, to love in ways that will break your heart, to love, to love, to love

    Today, like every day, brings challenges. What will your promises mean tonight?
    Will you become a part of the Church’s future, its healing, its commitment to love in a sometimes loveless world.

    This is your decision and in every way, the outcome depends upon how you fulfill the words you are about to speak.




  7. February 22, 2019
    The Feast of the Chair of St. Peter
    Very Rev. Denis Robinson, OSB
    You are Peter and upon this rock I will build my Church.
    I wish that today we could whisk ourselves to the airport in Louisville, and then to Atlanta and then to Rome, where we would be met by my buddy Jemmi and taken by bus to our hotel and then, after a short break, we would walk over to Saint Peter’s basilica and go through security and walk to the back of the Church and see the wild, and admittedly somewhat tacky, sculpture of Gian Lorenzo Bernini known as the Chair of Peter. It is an overwrought piece of baroque over-exuberance. The throne of Peter supported by four oversized doctors of the Church, surrounded by little naked gold angels singing and trumpeting surmounted by a stained glass window of the Holy Spirit spraying down magnificence on, well, everything. In essence, though, the sculpture is a reliquary, a large one, which was made to basically house a kitchen chair, the ancient relic of the chair of Peter, the kitchen chair for which we have a wonderful “furniturial” feast to observe today.

    Today we celebrate a kitchen chair housed in the splendor of baroque tackiness. But perhaps there is more.

    I was interested in praying with the Office of Readings this morning of the grand vision of Peter’s authority given in the second reading from Saint Leo the Great. Leo was great because he, as a successor of Peter, undoubtedly had the ability to weave a magic message about Petrine authority and power. Hence the Council of Chalcedon.

    And there is truth in that assertion, a truth that is played out for us daily in the unfolding drama of the Church embroiled now in controversy, but resting, rather assuredly on the authority of Peter.

    But what is that authority?
    You are Peter and upon this rock I will build my Church.
    What does Leo say?

    “Out of the whole world, one man, Peter, is chosen to preside at the calling of all nations, and to be set over all of the apostles and all the fathers of the Church.”
    What we do not have in today’s Gospel reading, nor in the Gospel of Matthew itself, is the admonishment of Peter we have in the other Gospels: When Peter tries to take charge of Jesus’ message he is told: Get behind me Satan. You are a stumbling block to me.
    Peter had problems. Peter had doubts. Peter had denials. Peter had moments of real stupidity, so it is perhaps quite prescient that he should be represented by a kitchen chair, even if we choose to enrobe that chair in baroque splendor.

    Perhaps it is so with us.

    It is clear, Jesus is not preaching a world into existence that is built upon what is expected, what is fair and not fair, upon the strict rules of justice. Jesus does not choose the most intelligent, the most socially prominent, the best placed.

    Jesus chooses a kitchen chair and wraps it up in splendor.
    You are Peter and upon this rock I will build my Church.
    Rockhead, I choose you because in the Gospel …

    Jesus is preaching a Word, in which we are all asked, every day, in every way, to go beyond

    Beyond what is comfortable.

    Beyond what is convenient

    Beyond what is easy

    Beyond what we like

    Beyond what the Law says.

    Beyond our social or ecclesial politics

    Beyond the confines of our tastes and personal discriminations

    Beyond the periphery of what we believe and profess is possible

    Beyond the damning minimalism that is controlling our world and controlling the teetering structures of the Church today

    Beyond our ancestors and our progeny

    Beyond our limitations and our understanding of fairness, justice, whatever …

    The plan of God poured out on Peter exists in this: That God so loved us that he intends that we should rise to be the best we can become, and it is God himself who makes this claim, and God himself who defines what is best. He chooses the weak, like Peter, and makes them strong. He chooses us in our weakness and makes the kitchen chair become a glorious throne

    He intended it for Peter. He intends it for us

    Our work brothers and sisters in this world is to become a slave of God’s will.

    That is the reality of God.

    The reality of God exists in our become willing martyrs of God’s promise

    The reality of God depends upon the perpetual positive energy we are called to pour on the wounds of our troubled neighbors those crouched in the pain of confusion and doubt

    The reality of God is the reality of simplicity

    The reality of God is the reality of honesty

    The reality of God is the Truth of sublimity

    The reality of God is enshrined for us in the crucified savior whose wounds call out from the wood of the cross to a world besieged by the accident of sin, sin that extends even to the baroque splendor of Peter’s basilica. These are wounds that Peter himself would endure, and from those wounds the upside down wounds of a simple fisherman, we continue to hear an invitation, one spoken to us from the simplicity of a kitchen chair:

    What will we give?
    You are Peter and upon this rock I will build my Church.

    Image Source
Subscribe
Subscribe
Fr. Denis Robinson, OSB
Fr. Denis Robinson, OSB
Fr. Denis Robinson, OSB

Fr. Denis Robinson, OSB, is president-rector of Saint Meinrad School of Theology in St. Meinrad, IN. A Benedictine monk, he is also an assistant professor of systematic theology. A Mississippi native, Fr. Denis attended Saint Meinrad College and School of Theology, earning a bachelor's degree in philosophy in 1989 and a Master of Divinity in 1993. From 1993-97, he was parochial vicar for the Cathedral of the Immaculate Conception in Memphis, TN. He joined the Saint Meinrad monastery in August 1997. Fr. Denis also attended the Catholic University of Louvain, Belgium, where he received a master’s degree in theology in 2002, a licentiate in sacred theology in 2003, and doctorates in sacred theology and philosophy in 2007.

View my complete profile
Links
Blog Archive
Categories
Loading
Dynamic Views theme. Powered by Blogger. Report Abuse.